Please comment on this post so that I know that you are able to find it. Make sure you include your first name and first initial of your last name on the first line.
At the beginning of the story the bags of the two main characters were on one side of the station. I think that Ernest Hemingway is trying to represent with this one view of the situation that the American and the girl were arguing about, which is the abortion of their baby. Throughout the story we notice that the American (father of the baby) does not want the birth of the child, but in contrast the girl (mother of the baby) really want to have this kid. Obviously the final decision has to be in favor of one of the two characters. If we read the last page, almost at the end of the story, the American say to the girl “I’d better take the bags over to the other side of the station” and Hemingway tells us that the girl smiled at him. That makes me think they decide to have the baby. Why? Because he was the one who took the bags to the other side of the station, so I believe he’s the one who change his opinion, and also by her expression at him I think she felt comfortable with that. That means he support her with the decision of having the baby.
I think that what happened at the end of the story was the women abort the baby because he wants to keep his current lifestyle. I conclude that for two events that will happen. The first is when the girl was looked the bags with all the hotel labels on them are symbolic of his vivacious spirit. If the woman goes ahead with the pregnancy, he would have to settle down and raise a family, which would mean forgoing his youthful desires of seeing the world. The other event is that at the end of the story the American asks to the girl' Do you feel better.’ I feel fine, "she said.’There's nothing wrong with me. I feel fine." This dialogue make me think that she abort the baby because the American asked to her.
I think that the American Boy and Jig are waiting for the train. After waiting several minutes the train arrived. They took their bags and enter to the train. -“Look at the mountains, how the White Elephants disappears “, said Jig. Then, they continue talking about with their problem. -Jig Said: “Well, I’m confused. I’m not really sure about what to do, but I don’t care about me anyway”. -“I think it is the best thing to do, it is simple’” the boy said. Jig was thinking about her decision during the trip. -“I love you”, said the boy. Both want are very confused. After two hours, they arrived to the city. They went to the place where there are going to stay. They talked about the problem during the night and then they decide what to do. Next day, in the morning they visited the doctor office and then they resolve their problem. -“The White Elephant disappear”, Jig said to the American Boy.
How wonderful that you decided to make that decision – he comments
I tried to make the act and effort for this relationship to work and make it for both of us. – she comments
She thinks that the relationship will work out if she makes the decision of ending the white elephants. This decision will not be for sure definite. Try to understand that things between us, are not going to be like the beginning of this relationship. This relationship is over. I just wanted you to loose the baby. But you only think of you. And there was a complete silence in the bar.
She shut up and no words came out of her mouth after the things she heard. She only knows that there is nothing she can do about the situation. She just took the train and change the direction of her life.
I think that the end of the story was as follow. After five minutes the train arrived. Then the man and the girl boarded the train to Madrid. When they arrived, he said good bye to her and told her that he needed time and space to think things very carefully. The girl went home very sad. Nine months went by and they never saw each other again. She decided to have her baby. It was a beautiful baby girl. When one year had passed, he decide to return to see what decision she had made. When he knocked, he was surprised to see that she had gotten married. She met a good man who had accepted her the way she was willing to care for the like if it was his. When he found out about this he preferred to leave and her be happy. Even though he wanted to see his daughter, he continued to think that he was not prepared to be a father.
I think that at the end of the story, they took the train and she got her own way, she kept the baby, it wasn't a white elephant no more. She realized that the only thing he wanted was having her to continue his stylelife with no responsabilities. She began to care about her. He took his own way too. He just go in search for another woman with who could take some beers.
They took the train. When they arrive she went with her family, but they do not lose communication and about a month later…
Hello, the woman said. Hi! How are you?, the man said. Who is it? Isn’t whom I think, really? Yeah, is me… but tell me how are you? Oh, I am very fine. And you?
I am very fine too. The purpose of this call is because I want to see you and finish the beer that we start about a month ago. I was thinking in many things and I want to talk with you, the man said.
Ok, I will go to talk with you, but I cant drink beers. But, why? Its very simple, think and you know why, she said.
Really, this is excellent news. So, see you tomorrow in the Millie’s Cafeteria.
Ok, you are here! We need to talk many things. Bye, and see you tomorrow.
Next Day. Oh my God, you look beautiful, the man said. Thanks, but tell me, what do you want to talk with me? Thanks for take the best decision, I LOVE YOU. Do you want to be my wife? , he said. WAO! Are you sure? WAO!!! Yes , I want.
My point of view is that the woman made the best decision, she didn't abort. Plus, she made a good choice because the poor creature that is inside of her is not responsible for their acts. For that reason I think she decided to take care of that creature who will born later on. This is like good people think, they are not afraid of life's obstacles and they are face to face with it. Finally, they are going to live happy because when that creature get born, both, the man and the woman, are going to be like OH GOD my son, and then they are going to say, we made a goo decision.
When i read the story I didn't undertstand the theme, but I read the story many times and understand the message. About the final of the story I believe that she aborts the baby. it is something bad because this creature didn't request to come at the world. If you acts bad you need to be responsible with the consequences of your acts.
Alone excuses was enough for kill an inocent creature. for me abortion is a crime and need to be punished by the justice, but if it is not punished in the earth, in the sky God see all of our acts here.I think that two parts or two points of view (man vs woman) needs to be responsible before gone to do something and need to be in agreement thinking in the consequences. in the live our not be able to do crazy acts if you are not prepare to be responsible. In other way the woman don't need to do mans decisions, woman have the power to decede too. If a man didn't is responsible of his acts, you need to be responsible and thinking in this creature, that in the future will be a lawyer, engineer or a teacher. I think that womans have the desicion in his hand if the man didn't have the mature to affront the situation.
This is a good story and have many themes to think and comment about it.
In my opinion, this story is so interesting because is about two peoples that meet each other and talk about of a social problem, but I concerned the author must be give to this story an ending. This story hills like a white elephants is a story in where the author present a common problem, the abortion. The pregnant girl meets the American and has a conversation in which they together say them point of view but the girl who has the unwanted gift, think the best way to feel well is the abort. I believe the end of the story is that girl forgets the idea of abortion and have the baby and life happy together. I think it, because I do not imagine she could live with the guilt of consciousness for having killed the baby and then feel guilty and sorry all their life for the thing that she did, because the abortion is a sin against God.
In this short story Ernest Hemingway using symbolism at his best, explains using two characters the hard decision of an abortion, the first things is that he uses the rareness of a white elephant, to explain the magic of having a child. White represents an unborn child, purity and innocence. Using the train station as a setting he sets a stressful mood in the story, they have two option, (the Amercians and the girl)having the baby or not. The author uses the trains to symbolize this decision. The story continues and they are having a big discussion about it, even dough the author doesn't use the word abortion not even once. The American takes the bags to the next railroad but he comes back and smiles at the girl, it gives the impression that the decision he took was the right one, the one the girl was looking for. But basically the story has not resolution this is the why of the question(what do you think happens). But I think that they lived very happy because finally are mutually supportive and took the decision that the child was born. Then the girl and men were happy with your child and the woman said the men saw that it was the best decision we makes in our lives.
I think that the end of the story is very simple and a reality of our life. A young couple had a difficult situation because the girl is pregnant and they are very confused. In my opinion the girl enter to the railroad and then begin a new life in your destiny, but a long time the boy decide searching and begin a new life. The problem is that the girl no liked beginning a new life with the boy because in the difficult situation he going to other place. In the life one bad determination can be represented forever, everyday the young showing difficult situation but the most important is decide the best for all. Many people thinks that the pregnancy is the end of the world, but this is incorrect, the pregnancy is the beginning of new life and a stage to take many responsibilities.
In my opinion the debate comes all the way to the end of the story in which in a form I think where he is taking the bags then when he is coming back he looked at the tracks and could not see the train and this for me represent the dilema between the man and the woman and the abortion and he could not see the right decision to take and then he looked at she and she is smiling to him but he do not know if she wants to abort or not. I thinkat the end of the they will keep the baby because the two of them seem very calmed so they two may have took the decision of keeping the baby because they were gonna live with that guilt in their hearts for the rest of their lives.
Fidel A To me the ending part of Hills Like White Elephants it is a little unclear, because in the story it is not specified if the young lady decided to abort or to keep the baby. But according to the reading and in my opinion the young lady decided to keep with the baby and not abort. I think this because although the man is have more experience the young lady still have something within her that tells her to not abort especially when she said to the man " I don`t care about me". which to me means that in a way she is care about the baby.
Linoshka S. Sec 060 Ending of “Hills like white elephants” ‘Do you feel better?’ he asked. ‘I feel fine,’ she said. ‘There’s nothing wrong with me. I feel fine.’
The American and the girl finished their beer, and then she looked again at the hills and the field of grain and trees along the banks of the Ebro. ‘But, what if I want something to happen? ‘Nothing will happen; everything is going to be all right. ‘Would you still loving me? The American did not say anything. The girl kept saying: ‘Something is part of us, and we can make it through. We can still be happy and have everything.’ ‘Can we have another beer?’ said the American. ‘No thanks, I am fine.’ Only two minutes were left before the train arrives to the station. The girl was convince that nothing was wrong with her, but the American was convince that something was wrong, and if he didn’t do something, everything would be different for the rest of his life. The train arrived to the station. The American took the two bags and looked again at the labels of the different hotels that they went and said: ‘I really like those labels’ The American walked inside the train and the girl followed him. The train left the station and the girl looked one more time at the hills and the trees of the valley. Then she took one of the bags and went to the back of the train to get some sleep. When the train stopped in the next station the American took his bag and went to wake up the girl. ‘Jig, wake up, let’s go.’ The girl opened her eyes and looked at him; then she closed her eyes and got to sleep again.
Ending of “Hills Like White Elephants” ‘Do you feel better? ‘ he asked. ‘I feel fine.’ She said. ’There’s nothing wrong with me. I feel fine.’ ‘ She finished her beer. ‘ Let’s go the train is coming, ’ she said. Then the man help her to stand from the table and she feels like he thought she were not fine. Then both move to the chairs in front of the railroad to see the arrival of the train. One minute later they listened a strong noise in their right ears. The man said here we go! There’s the train. Five seconds later from his words, they perceive another strong noise from their left ears. That was the other train which comes in opposite direction. In that moment the woman had a vision. In the vision she saw how they will be in the future after the operation. There where them both in America living their lives, traveling the world and enjoying everything. But she wasn’t a happy woman. She needs something, needs to have a family. After that short and fast vision she decided on what to do. She looks him at his eyes and said his name. Then the man response; what happen? That will be! She said. And the man was totally lost on what she was saying. Then the woman said; that will be the name of my son. The reaction on the man wasn’t the best, and he look at her. He saw in her face a determined woman and sure in her decision. He liked the attitude she was taking in that moment. He took a deep breath and said; o right Jig, I want you to know that I love you, and I will support you in all your decisions. Also asked her for a forgive for push her to take that decision. After his word the woman feels a happiness inside her heart like never before, and as a result of this she hug you. Finally the train arrived, and they entered aboard together.
Wesley A., ending of White Elephants: White Elephant ending by Wesley A.
While waiting for the train like everybody else, the American told Jig ''dont worry, i'll be al right.'' Jig just stood there, the only thing she said was ''finally the train has arrived''. While they were in the train the American slept, and Jig was looking out the window, her head was full of ideas.
She saw many things; the green grass, birds flying, and beautiful hills, ''the landscape here aint that dry, hot and ugly like at the train station,'' and the hills here...
Jig woke the American, he told her what happened,
Jig told him''look at the hills, this hills dont look like white elephants.''
What do they look like? he asked her
Jig said; '' they look like...
When she was about to finish talking, the train stopped, the American said;
Finally, we are here, you can tell me later what you wanted to tell me, come on lets go to the place where they can operate you, is near.
They got out of the train, he picked up the 2 bags. He ask her if she felt ok, she didnt say anything, just stood, there. The American ask her what was wrong with her, Jig said;
''Do you know how those hills look like''
He said; ''Like white elephants, right?''
Maybe to you, but to me they resemble life, and unborn life that needs to be born.
The American stood there quiet, Jig said;
''I love you, but if it means to be with you that I have to loose this blessing, then im sorry, goodbye.''
With nothing else said, both of them dissapeared, and they never saw themselves again.
Janice A. Reading Hills like white elephants is very complicated to understand because we can find some symbols with incredible meanings. The main topic is abortion, which we note that through the story is the conflict between a couple with different views. This story is unusual because it contains an unconcluded end, which was and is up to the reader’s imagination. For me what happened in the end was the following. After waiting for the train she went back to the American and told him she was all right. The first thing that comes to mind is the disagreement that the girl has about abortion. This leads me to think that she decided to wait for the next day train to continue the dialogue with the American. It was a speech full of insults and she showed him she was going to defend his baby with all her strength. Despite everything the girl said the American remained committed to her abortion. The girl is overcome with beer and beer told the American that if he continued to insist to keep the relationship between she would take the next train from 5:00 a.m. The stubborn man finally decided that she is going to take the decision, but he would not change his mind. She told him that she was going to meet him before the arrival of the train to tell him her decision. The girl was thinking all night about what her decision, it was a battle with his mind. The next morning she told him she was not going to abort, the relationship was over, not to look for her and that she will get back to her home where she was going to find love for her baby. The American remained silent, without having time to speak. The train arrived and she left quickly. She swore to protect her baby from anyone and I am sure that this was a wise decision in reading.
This story talk about two guys that are in a relationship. She get pregnant and obviously they didnt want the baby. I said obviously because today day the people dont want babys. I think the storys ends that the time pass , finnaly the baby arrive and the decided to have the baby.They begin to love the baby. When they notice they love the baby and want to remain him, they started to protect it. I think that was the best desition, I am telling that because I have a baby and is the most precious think God give me.h
This history is very interesting because they are two common people that discussing socials problems. In this story the author present the principal title the abortion. I think that the author use the train which a symbolism the decision of the woman that I believe she decide having the baby or she having abortion. I think that decision is important in the live of this girl and any people can choose the decision for the girl. I like to think that the girl can take the best decision for your live. But I think that the abortion is a difficult decision because I believe that if a baby can affect the mother’s live emotional or physically, if the girl was rape I believe that the abortion is an option. I believe that if a couple having sex an unprotected and she have a baby I think that the abortion is unacceptable because the girl know the consequence of having sex without protection.
I think that with the final words of the girl, Jig, she took a decision. I think at the final they have the child. He tries to persuade her to abort the baby all the way, but I think she want the baby when she pleased him to shut up. I think in that moment she is thinking in what to do. I think that at the final they have their baby and established a family and ended their before lifestyle. I think it was hard at the beginning, but at the final with the born of the baby the man change his mind. The couple had a lot of troubles in the way but at the final they are happy to decide to have their child. They live together for years and this baby was the first child of the new family that they creates.
Viviannette M. INGL 3202-060 Hills like white elephants
The end of this story in unpredictable, because it doesn't have a really ending, it leaves us without any conclusion. In other ways we need to assume what happened at the end. It will take an exceptionally perceptive reader to understand or realize what happened. Maybe one of the possible ending of the story would be that they are waiting the train coming from Barcelona that will take them (the man and the girl) to Madrid, where the girl will have an abortion. Or a second possible ending it could be that the girl decides to not have or practice an abortion and have the baby. At the very end of the story the man asked the girl "do you feel better?'' and the girl responded "there's nothing wrong with me", "I feel fine". This last sentence leaves us with an interrogation on our mind, because maybe the girl "feels fine'' because she got an abortion or maybe because she decides to stay pregnant and have the baby.
End of Hills Like White Elephants After a short period of time the express arrived, and everyone on the station began to board the train including the American and the girl. Right before two minutes had passed the express began its course. Inside, it could only be heard the clinging of the rails. It would take another 3 hours to get to Madrid. The girl was looking outside her window starring at mountains on the horizon and the American sitting quietly beside her. “Are you ok?” “Mjm”, she replied still staring outside. “Are you sure?” “Yes! Why do you ask?” “Because you haven’t talked to me since we left the station” “I’m just tired” “I just wanted to know if everything is alright between us.” “Why wouldn’t they be?” she replied “After this is over everything will be as they used to, as you wanted it” “I knew it! I knew there was something wrong” “So?!” “Why are you being like this? He ask “I already told you, you don’t have to do it if you don’t want to” “Well, I want to do it, as soon as we get off this train” “What! I know you’re upset but this is insane, take it easy” Oh!! She cried. “I’m not feeling so good” The girl got up and ran to the restrooms to see if washing her face with cold water would make her feel better. The American sat there waiting for her worried and wondering what will happen after they arrive. After several minutes the girl returns to her seat with tear eyes. “Are you alright?” “There’s no need to worry, at least now things got the way they used to”
Nora F.
ReplyDeleteI can comment here.
Janice A.
ReplyDeleteWesley A. is here
ReplyDeleteRaúl H. ... here
ReplyDeleteOBED M .... is here
ReplyDeleteGabriel M. is here
ReplyDeleteIvettemarie O. ... is here
ReplyDeleteBryan M. is here
ReplyDeleteRafael A
ReplyDeleteHector A. is here
ReplyDeleteLani M.
ReplyDeleteDamaris B.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteIriselies M
ReplyDeleteSullymar D is here
ReplyDeleteSandra
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteSullymar D
ReplyDeleteAt the beginning of the story the bags of the two main characters were on one side of the station. I think that Ernest Hemingway is trying to represent with this one view of the situation that the American and the girl were arguing about, which is the abortion of their baby. Throughout the story we notice that the American (father of the baby) does not want the birth of the child, but in contrast the girl (mother of the baby) really want to have this kid. Obviously the final decision has to be in favor of one of the two characters. If we read the last page, almost at the end of the story, the American say to the girl “I’d better take the bags over to the other side of the station” and Hemingway tells us that the girl smiled at him. That makes me think they decide to have the baby. Why? Because he was the one who took the bags to the other side of the station, so I believe he’s the one who change his opinion, and also by her expression at him I think she felt comfortable with that. That means he support her with the decision of having the baby.
Ivettemarie O
ReplyDeleteI think that what happened at the end of the story was the women abort the baby because he wants to keep his current lifestyle. I conclude that for two events that will happen. The first is when the girl was looked the bags with all the hotel labels on them are symbolic of his vivacious spirit. If the woman goes ahead with the pregnancy, he would have to settle down and raise a family, which would mean forgoing his youthful desires of seeing the world. The other event is that at the end of the story the American asks to the girl' Do you feel better.’ I feel fine, "she said.’There's nothing wrong with me. I feel fine." This dialogue make me think that she abort the baby because the American asked to her.
frabeth s
ReplyDeleteI think that the American Boy and Jig are waiting for the train. After waiting several minutes the train arrived. They took their bags and enter to the train.
ReplyDelete-“Look at the mountains, how the White Elephants disappears “, said Jig.
Then, they continue talking about with their problem.
-Jig Said: “Well, I’m confused. I’m not really sure about what to do, but I don’t care about me anyway”.
-“I think it is the best thing to do, it is simple’” the boy said.
Jig was thinking about her decision during the trip.
-“I love you”, said the boy.
Both want are very confused. After two hours, they arrived to the city. They went to the place where there are going to stay. They talked about the problem during the night and then they decide what to do. Next day, in the morning they visited the doctor office and then they resolve their problem.
-“The White Elephant disappear”, Jig said to the American Boy.
How wonderful that you decided to make that decision – he comments
ReplyDeleteI tried to make the act and effort for this relationship to work and make it for both of us. – she comments
She thinks that the relationship will work out if she makes the decision of ending the white elephants. This decision will not be for sure definite. Try to understand that things between us, are not going to be like the beginning of this relationship. This relationship is over. I just wanted you to loose the baby. But you only think of you. And there was a complete silence in the bar.
She shut up and no words came out of her mouth after the things she heard. She only knows that there is nothing she can do about the situation. She just took the train and change the direction of her life.
I think that the end of the story was as follow. After five minutes the train arrived. Then the man and the girl boarded the train to Madrid. When they arrived, he said good bye to her and told her that he needed time and space to think things very carefully. The girl went home very sad.
ReplyDeleteNine months went by and they never saw each other again. She decided to have her baby. It was a beautiful baby girl. When one year had passed, he decide to return to see what decision she had made. When he knocked, he was surprised to see that she had gotten married. She met a good man who had accepted her the way she was willing to care for the like if it was his. When he found out about this he preferred to leave and her be happy. Even though he wanted to see his daughter, he continued to think that he was not prepared to be a father.
I think that at the end of the story, they took the train and she got her own way, she kept the baby, it wasn't a white elephant no more. She realized that the only thing he wanted was having her to continue his stylelife with no responsabilities. She began to care about her. He took his own way too. He just go in search for another woman with who could take some beers.
ReplyDeleteMy ending is…
ReplyDeleteThey took the train. When they arrive she went with her family, but they do not lose communication and about a month later…
Hello, the woman said.
Hi! How are you?, the man said.
Who is it? Isn’t whom I think, really?
Yeah, is me… but tell me how are you?
Oh, I am very fine. And you?
I am very fine too. The purpose of this call is because I want to see you and finish the beer that we start about a month ago. I was thinking in many things and I want to talk with you, the man said.
Ok, I will go to talk with you, but I cant drink beers.
But, why?
Its very simple, think and you know why, she said.
Really, this is excellent news. So, see you tomorrow in the Millie’s Cafeteria.
Ok, you are here! We need to talk many things. Bye, and see you tomorrow.
Next Day.
Oh my God, you look beautiful, the man said.
Thanks, but tell me, what do you want to talk with me?
Thanks for take the best decision, I LOVE YOU. Do you want to be my wife? , he said.
WAO! Are you sure? WAO!!! Yes , I want.
My point of view is that the woman made the best decision, she didn't abort. Plus, she made a good choice because the poor creature that is inside of her is not responsible for their acts. For that reason I think she decided to take care of that creature who will born later on. This is like good people think, they are not afraid of life's obstacles and they are face to face with it. Finally, they are going to live happy because when that creature get born, both, the man and the woman, are going to be like OH GOD my son, and then they are going to say, we made a goo decision.
ReplyDeleteWhen i read the story I didn't undertstand the theme, but I read the story many times and understand the message. About the final of the story I believe that she aborts the baby. it is something bad because this creature didn't request to come at the world. If you acts bad you need to be responsible with the consequences of your acts.
ReplyDeleteAlone excuses was enough for kill an inocent creature. for me abortion is a crime and need to be punished by the justice, but if it is not punished in the earth, in the sky God see all of our acts here.I think that two parts or two points of view (man vs woman) needs to be responsible before gone to do something and need to be in agreement thinking in the consequences. in the live our not be able to do crazy acts if you are not prepare to be responsible. In other way the woman don't need to do mans decisions, woman have the power to decede too. If a man didn't is responsible of his acts, you need to be responsible and thinking in this creature, that in the future will be a lawyer, engineer or a teacher. I think that womans have the desicion in his hand if the man didn't have the mature to affront the situation.
This is a good story and have many themes to think and comment about it.
In my opinion, this story is so interesting because is about two peoples that meet each other and talk about of a social problem, but I concerned the author must be give to this story an ending. This story hills like a white elephants is a story in where the author present a common problem, the abortion. The pregnant girl meets the American and has a conversation in which they together say them point of view but the girl who has the unwanted gift, think the best way to feel well is the abort. I believe the end of the story is that girl forgets the idea of abortion and have the baby and life happy together. I think it, because I do not imagine she could live with the guilt of consciousness for having killed the baby and then feel guilty and sorry all their life for the thing that she did, because the abortion is a sin against God.
ReplyDeleteIn this short story Ernest Hemingway using symbolism at his best, explains using two characters the hard decision of an abortion, the first things is that he uses the rareness of a white elephant, to explain the magic of having a child. White represents an unborn child, purity and innocence. Using the train station as a setting he sets a stressful mood in the story, they have two option, (the Amercians and the girl)having the baby or not. The author uses the trains to symbolize this decision. The story continues and they are having a big discussion about it, even dough the author doesn't use the word abortion not even once. The American takes the bags to the next railroad but he comes back and smiles at the girl, it gives the impression that the decision he took was the right one, the one the girl was looking for. But basically the story has not resolution this is the why of the question(what do you think happens). But I think that they lived very happy because finally are mutually supportive and took the decision that the child was born. Then the girl and men were happy with your child and the woman said the men saw that it was the best decision we makes in our lives.
ReplyDeleteI think that the end of the story is very simple and a reality of our life. A young couple had a difficult situation because the girl is pregnant and they are very confused. In my opinion the girl enter to the railroad and then begin a new life in your destiny, but a long time the boy decide searching and begin a new life. The problem is that the girl no liked beginning a new life with the boy because in the difficult situation he going to other place. In the life one bad determination can be represented forever, everyday the young showing difficult situation but the most important is decide the best for all. Many people thinks that the pregnancy is the end of the world, but this is incorrect, the pregnancy is the beginning of new life and a stage to take many responsibilities.
ReplyDeleteIn my opinion the debate comes all the way to the end of the story in which in a form I think where he is taking the bags then when he is coming back he looked at the tracks and could not see the train and this for me represent the dilema between the man and the woman and the abortion and he could not see the right decision to take and then he looked at she and she is smiling to him but he do not know if she wants to abort or not. I thinkat the end of the they will keep the baby because the two of them seem very calmed so they two may have took the decision of keeping the baby because they were gonna live with that guilt in their hearts for the rest of their lives.
ReplyDeleteFidel A
ReplyDeleteTo me the ending part of Hills Like White Elephants it is a little unclear, because in the story it is not specified if the young lady decided to abort or to keep the baby. But according to the reading and in my opinion the young lady decided to keep with the baby and not abort. I think this because although the man is have more experience the young lady still have something within her that tells her to not abort especially when she said to the man " I don`t care about me". which to me means that in a way she is care about the baby.
Hills test
ReplyDeleteLinoshka S.
ReplyDeleteSec 060
Ending of “Hills like white elephants”
‘Do you feel better?’ he asked.
‘I feel fine,’ she said. ‘There’s nothing wrong with me. I feel fine.’
The American and the girl finished their beer, and then she looked again at the hills and the field of grain and trees along the banks of the Ebro.
‘But, what if I want something to happen?
‘Nothing will happen; everything is going to be all right.
‘Would you still loving me?
The American did not say anything. The girl kept saying:
‘Something is part of us, and we can make it through. We can still be happy and have everything.’
‘Can we have another beer?’ said the American.
‘No thanks, I am fine.’
Only two minutes were left before the train arrives to the station. The girl was convince that nothing was wrong with her, but the American was convince that something was wrong, and if he didn’t do something, everything would be different for the rest of his life.
The train arrived to the station. The American took the two bags and looked again at the labels of the different hotels that they went and said:
‘I really like those labels’
The American walked inside the train and the girl followed him. The train left the station and the girl looked one more time at the hills and the trees of the valley. Then she took one of the bags and went to the back of the train to get some sleep.
When the train stopped in the next station the American took his bag and went to wake up the girl.
‘Jig, wake up, let’s go.’
The girl opened her eyes and looked at him; then she closed her eyes and got to sleep again.
Ending of “Hills Like White Elephants”
ReplyDelete‘Do you feel better? ‘ he asked.
‘I feel fine.’ She said. ’There’s nothing wrong with me. I feel fine.’
‘ She finished her beer. ‘ Let’s go the train is coming, ’ she said.
Then the man help her to stand from the table and she feels like he thought she were not fine. Then both move to the chairs in front of the railroad to see the arrival of the train. One minute later they listened a strong noise in their right ears. The man said here we go! There’s the train. Five seconds later from his words, they perceive another strong noise from their left ears. That was the other train which comes in opposite direction. In that moment the woman had a vision. In the vision she saw how they will be in the future after the operation. There where them both in America living their lives, traveling the world and enjoying everything. But she wasn’t a happy woman. She needs something, needs to have a family. After that short and fast vision she decided on what to do. She looks him at his eyes and said his name. Then the man response; what happen? That will be! She said. And the man was totally lost on what she was saying. Then the woman said; that will be the name of my son. The reaction on the man wasn’t the best, and he look at her. He saw in her face a determined woman and sure in her decision. He liked the attitude she was taking in that moment. He took a deep breath and said; o right Jig, I want you to know that I love you, and I will support you in all your decisions. Also asked her for a forgive for push her to take that decision. After his word the woman feels a happiness inside her heart like never before, and as a result of this she hug you. Finally the train arrived, and they entered aboard together.
Wesley A., ending of White Elephants:
ReplyDeleteWhite Elephant ending by Wesley A.
While waiting for the train like everybody else, the American told Jig ''dont worry, i'll be al right.'' Jig just stood there, the only thing she said was ''finally the train has arrived''. While they were in the train the American slept, and Jig was looking out the window, her head was full of ideas.
She saw many things; the green grass, birds flying, and beautiful hills, ''the landscape here aint that dry, hot and ugly like at the train station,'' and the hills here...
Jig woke the American, he told her what happened,
Jig told him''look at the hills, this hills dont look like white elephants.''
What do they look like? he asked her
Jig said; '' they look like...
When she was about to finish talking, the train stopped, the American said;
Finally, we are here, you can tell me later what you wanted to tell me, come on lets go to the place where they can operate you, is near.
They got out of the train, he picked up the 2 bags. He ask her if she felt ok, she didnt say anything, just stood, there. The American ask her what was wrong with her, Jig said;
''Do you know how those hills look like''
He said; ''Like white elephants, right?''
Maybe to you, but to me they resemble life, and unborn life that needs to be born.
The American stood there quiet, Jig said;
''I love you, but if it means to be with you that I have to loose this blessing, then im sorry, goodbye.''
With nothing else said, both of them dissapeared, and they never saw themselves again.
Janice A.
ReplyDeleteReading Hills like white elephants is very complicated to understand because we can find some symbols with incredible meanings. The main topic is abortion, which we note that through the story is the conflict between a couple with different views. This story is unusual because it contains an unconcluded end, which was and is up to the reader’s imagination. For me what happened in the end was the following. After waiting for the train she went back to the American and told him she was all right. The first thing that comes to mind is the disagreement that the girl has about abortion. This leads me to think that she decided to wait for the next day train to continue the dialogue with the American. It was a speech full of insults and she showed him she was going to defend his baby with all her strength. Despite everything the girl said the American remained committed to her abortion. The girl is overcome with beer and beer told the American that if he continued to insist to keep the relationship between she would take the next train from 5:00 a.m. The stubborn man finally decided that she is going to take the decision, but he would not change his mind. She told him that she was going to meet him before the arrival of the train to tell him her decision. The girl was thinking all night about what her decision, it was a battle with his mind. The next morning she told him she was not going to abort, the relationship was over, not to look for her and that she will get back to her home where she was going to find love for her baby. The American remained silent, without having time to speak. The train arrived and she left quickly. She swore to protect her baby from anyone and I am sure that this was a wise decision in reading.
Kristal L
ReplyDeleteThis story talk about two guys that are in a relationship. She get pregnant and obviously they didnt want the baby. I said obviously because today day the people dont want babys. I think the storys ends that the time pass , finnaly the baby arrive and the decided to have the baby.They begin to love the baby. When they notice they love the baby and want to remain him, they started to protect it. I think that was the best desition, I am telling that because I have a baby and is the most precious think God give me.h
Kritzia H.
ReplyDeleteThis history is very interesting because they are two common people that discussing socials problems. In this story the author present the principal title the abortion. I think that the author use the train which a symbolism the decision of the woman that I believe she decide having the baby or she having abortion. I think that decision is important in the live of this girl and any people can choose the decision for the girl. I like to think that the girl can take the best decision for your live. But I think that the abortion is a difficult decision because I believe that if a baby can affect the mother’s live emotional or physically, if the girl was rape I believe that the abortion is an option. I believe that if a couple having sex an unprotected and she have a baby I think that the abortion is unacceptable because the girl know the consequence of having sex without protection.
I think that with the final words of the girl, Jig, she took a decision. I think at the final they have the child. He tries to persuade her to abort the baby all the way, but I think she want the baby when she pleased him to shut up. I think in that moment she is thinking in what to do. I think that at the final they have their baby and established a family and ended their before lifestyle. I think it was hard at the beginning, but at the final with the born of the baby the man change his mind. The couple had a lot of troubles in the way but at the final they are happy to decide to have their child. They live together for years and this baby was the first child of the new family that they creates.
ReplyDeleteViviannette M.
ReplyDeleteINGL 3202-060
Hills like white elephants
The end of this story in unpredictable, because it doesn't have a really ending, it leaves us without any conclusion. In other ways we need to assume what happened at the end. It will take an exceptionally perceptive reader to understand or realize what happened. Maybe one of the possible ending of the story would be that they are waiting the train coming from Barcelona that will take them (the man and the girl) to Madrid, where the girl will have an abortion. Or a second possible ending it could be that the girl decides to not have or practice an abortion and have the baby.
At the very end of the story the man asked the girl "do you feel better?'' and the girl responded "there's nothing wrong with me", "I feel fine". This last sentence leaves us with an interrogation on our mind, because maybe the girl "feels fine'' because she got an abortion or maybe because she decides to stay pregnant and have the baby.
End of Hills Like White Elephants
ReplyDeleteAfter a short period of time the express arrived, and everyone on the station began to board the train including the American and the girl. Right before two minutes had passed the express began its course. Inside, it could only be heard the clinging of the rails. It would take another 3 hours to get to Madrid. The girl was looking outside her window starring at mountains on the horizon and the American sitting quietly beside her.
“Are you ok?”
“Mjm”, she replied still staring outside.
“Are you sure?”
“Yes! Why do you ask?”
“Because you haven’t talked to me since we left the station”
“I’m just tired”
“I just wanted to know if everything is alright between us.”
“Why wouldn’t they be?” she replied “After this is over everything will be as they used to, as you wanted it”
“I knew it! I knew there was something wrong”
“So?!”
“Why are you being like this? He ask “I already told you, you don’t have to do it if you don’t want to”
“Well, I want to do it, as soon as we get off this train”
“What! I know you’re upset but this is insane, take it easy”
Oh!! She cried. “I’m not feeling so good”
The girl got up and ran to the restrooms to see if washing her face with cold water would make her feel better. The American sat there waiting for her worried and wondering what will happen after they arrive. After several minutes the girl returns to her seat with tear eyes.
“Are you alright?”
“There’s no need to worry, at least now things got the way they used to”